Identifying Reputable Journals With the proliferation of journal titles and frequent email solicitations for manuscripts, it can be challenging for authors to determine whether a journal is reputable. Sources that are primarily journalistic Sources written for a broad readership Sources that are advocacy or opinion-based. Students will often cite Einstein, Nelson Mandela, The It was founded by Arne Nss in 1958. Do not jump over the required words volume. Use them to develop a strong foundational understanding of the topic. All the advice on this site is general in nature. A high number of Cited By results can often be a measurement of credibility. started teaching that lecture, Information Websites that arent News Sources. One platform with which I am familiar is financed by a combination of a large ongoing government grant plus a single large annual subscription from a major reseach university; that platform publishes about a dozen journals. For web sources, the URL and layout should signify that it is trustworthy. This recent hijacking trend is particularly disturbing, says Dr. Franco, because the fakes piggyback on real brands and confuse even vigilant academics. Learning & Teaching: The International Journal of Higher Education in the Social Sciences (LATISS), Bibliography of Undergraduate Research Periodicals, The Stanford Journal of Science, Technology, and Society, Midwest Journal of Undergraduate Research (MJUR), Pi Sigma Alpha Undergraduate Journal of Politics. Depending on the type of information you need, your sources may vary. Legitimate science follows the scientific method, is unbiased and does not use emotional words. Ah, nice, the 378th article about OMICS journals & predatory publishing with all the details that any academic worth their title should know by knowbut I wish these articles would also spell out a more blunt truth: If you go to any journal page and a substantial amount of articles are published by academics on the global periphery, very often based at universities you didnt even know existed, chances are that this is a predatory journal. The information should be up to date and current. Simply put, why would you reference the book as if its a website when you can actually reference the book as a book? INQUIRY (INQ) is an open access, peer-reviewed journal whose mission is to improve health at both the public health and individual healthcare organization levels by enabling scientists, educators, healthcare practitioners, administrators, managers, and policymakers to translate their research and ideas into actionable outcomes. For instance, it seems that 40% of Pubmed Central (an OA aggregator) users are not researchers, but citizens (see http://bit.ly/2jfNfTr). Besides, a person should not just use sources to . Discuss what you find with your doctor before making any changes to your health care. This is a great place to kick off your research. Check for statistics and data within the article to back up the claims made by the author. The world of scholarly publishing is in serious trouble. In fact, Id recommend not ever even going onto these websites at all. Mine it for information, then go to Google Scholar and get an actual textbook or journal article to cite in your paper. Google scholar: This Internet search engine helps the user to locate scholarly literature in the form of articles and books, professional societies . Inspirational quotes are rarely if ever, used well in essays. Titles of his blog posts denouncing predatory journals and publishers include, More Rubbish from Hyderabad: Peertechz and >OMICS International Totally Sucks. Mr. Beall classifies both Peertechz and OMICS as predatory publishers. Primary sources are often considered the most credible in terms of providing evidence for your argument, as they give you direct evidence of what you are researching. Inquiry publishes research articles, symposia, special issues, target articles, review essays, and . Sometimes it is difficult to determine whether a magazine's focus is conservative, liberal or radical. If you need a decision more quickly, we offer the option of an expedited review track for a fee. That is why authoritarian governments seek to control access to information. INQUIRIES Journal, formerly Student Pulse, is an open-access academic journal that highlights the work of students at the undergraduate level and above. If you cite that website as an essay source, youll lose marks. Given the number and sophistication of predatory and mediocre journals and the lack of oversight and policing in the industry perhaps the most reasonable advice is to assume that all new journals are suspect, unless the journals criteria and content prove otherwise. The They usually do this to open their essay. Sometimes it is genuinely the most accurate and Q: What about plagiarism? Published on Together, these criteria form what is known as the CRAAP test. With the presence and advancement of new technologies, their usage for inquiry learning in university context is increasingly ubiquitous. Articles from scholarly, peer-reviewed, academic, and refereed journals are more credible than articles from popular or trade journals ('magazines') because they have gone through the most rigorous review process. Legitimate open access publishers, such as the Public Library of Science (PLOS) and BioMed Central, began about 20 years ago as the internet expanded. However, unlike blogs, published magazines usually do uphold journalistic standards of not publishing lies or slander that could result in litigation. Publishers websites should be easy to navigate, transparent in terms of contact names and methods, and shouldnt crash or suffer from ongoing technical problems. The journal requests that papers be b. A quick. What are examples of academic dishonesty? in Political Science from Northeastern while developing the journal as a side project. Does it look professional to you? It hasnt always been this bad. For more information, please see our and our Quoting the pope as an essay source might have its place in a religious studies class. [For web sources]: My sources URL suggests the domain is trustworthy, e.g. But, the trend is changing because of pressures to be more international and publish in English, says Dr. Larivire. The true and sound will survive. A short peer-review process and sudden request for fees are signs of a predatory journal. Unlike most other academic student publications, the journal has no official affiliation and is financially independent, supported by its users. articles meet that standard. If a journal does not provide such information, you may have found a "predatory journal." Our goal is to provide a credible and accessible venue for the dissemination of the best student scholarship into the public, professional, and academic discourse. . Directions | Directory | For Library Staff | Portal | About, 630-617-3160 | Reference: 630-617-3173 Some deans were unaware of the recent predatory ways in which these publishers are tricking academics, she says. There are reliable sources besides peer-reviewed journal, for example, books and web pages. Secondly, citing your teachers recent publications is cringe-worthy. However, in most circumstances, college students cannot integrate technologies to their inquiry learning in efficient ways or . The 3 key checks to tell if a source is reliable 1. So next time you use Google Books, cite the book, not the webpage. The barriers to launching a new operation are few and low, Mr. Beall says. But be smart about how you cite Google Books. This is the most common one on the whole list. Student Pulse changed its name to Inquiries Journal. When another reliable source quotes information from Gawker, it is preferable to cite that source instead. . Was the source created by someone directly involved in the events youre studying (primary), or by another researcher (secondary)? Although the scope of the journal is very wide in subject matter, it appears to strictly accept written articles as opposed to also accepting film, art work, or other cheating. Disclaimer: content on this website is for informational purposes only. IJR also invites readers to experience the news through a blend of products and services that enable them to actively participate in story selection, development, and promotion." coleman 533 stove carry case; trumpets in the sky alaska; replica designer swimwear vendors; Any student at the undergraduate level or above is invited to make a submission to the journal. I once asked one of the Nature journals I was considering submitting to whether acceptance of a submitted MS was independent of ability to pay the fee. People are copying the model from friends and uncles, because they see how easily theyre making profits. Predatory journals are run less like multinational corporations and more like syndicates, working independently of one another but using similar models, resources and methods. Government-affiliated websites end in .gov. Inquiries Journal was established in 2009 under the name Student Pulse by students at Northeastern University in Boston, Massachusetts. Backlinks to other sources are up-to-date and not broken. Some of these resources are considered popular sources whereas the others are considered scholarly sources. In fact, this model is fairly common. Thanks to PLOS and other big, credible publishers, open access models changed the culture of scholarly publishing for the better, making research more accessible. This could also give you insight into the author and publishers motivations. statement. second citation looks better, is better, and will not throw up a red flag to your The sources below are organized in the following manner: the first source is a website that is very reliable; the second source is a website that is not very reliable; the third source is a website that is in the middle of the spectrum, leaning more toward being unreliable. Some students and faculty are quite gullible, Dr. Lee says. Some applicants list 50-plus publications and we have to comb through each one to ensure its credible.. It can be very unclear (often by design!) A reputable journal or magazine should contain a bibliography for every article. I seem to recall that if a paper is accepted, one must pay the fee; so I withdrew the submission. If youre writing about teaching philosophy, dont cite a quote about education by Nelson Mandela. Read the sections of textbooks that are available to you, and paraphrase and/or quote that information in your essays. Inquiry can help to solve the problems of tomorrow in the classrooms of today. Theyre not supposed to be the final word on a topic, or even an authoritative and credible essay source. One of the top skills that your degree signifies is that youve got the skills to conduct high-quality research. In March 2014 we introduced the option of receiving an expedited review in which we provide a decision within 10-days, however the vast majority of submissions proceed through the normal track. This post is part of a three-part series on referencing scholarly articles. It is stated that they are unlikely to publish articles below 1,500 words and may ask that articles much longer than 7,000 words be narrowed and revised. Bealls List, the popular blacklist website compiled by Mr. Beall, contains more than 1,200 publications and 1,000 publishers that he calls potentially predatory. Tegan George. You write: all open-access journals have the air of the vanity press industry. Heres some advice: treat all these great topic-specific websites like Wikipedia. I know that I am old as well as old-fashioned, but to me all open-access journals have the air of the vanity press industry. There are a lot of sources out there, and it can be hard to tell whats credible and what isnt at first glance. But cite these authors in context. Won't other students be able to copy my work? Who publishes in Inquiries Journal? And, although it doesnt seem to apply tou your situation, even researchers dont have access to all the papers they need. Its become more difficult to hear real signals to hear about real, relevant scientific discoveries., In an effort to alert academics, Mr. Beall updated his Bealls List to include both AJPI and Pulsus as possible predators and wrote about the panic among staff and editors at many Canadian medical journals. There is definitely cross-over, but tarring most OA journals with this brush does a major disservice to the many parties who are trying to enhance access to good, scholarly, reputable information. A credible source is free from bias and backed up with evidence. Required fields are marked *. Your email address will not be published. When a student references my papers in their essays, I cringe. Youll get better marks. Google Scholar also has a function called Cited By that can show you where the author has been cited. The domain extension can help you understand what type of website youre dealing with. The FTC mentioned this in its case against the company. Confirmation bias, believing what is familiar, can steer you in the wrong direction. Before looking at how to turn such ideas into empirically testable research questions, it is worth looking at where such ideas come from in the first place. This goes well beyond predatory journals: predatory conferences are now also the norm. We accept submissions from students at the undergraduate level and above (in addition to works completed while the author was enrolled in a university setting). The definition of a credible source can change depending on the discipline, but in general, for academic writing, a credible source is one that is unbiased and is backed up with evidence. Theres one legitimate impact-factor supplier, and its Thomson Reuters, says Mr. Beall. You also write: the vast majority of people who want to read the academic literature have access to the library of an academic institution. Ms. Simpson, whos been an editor and writer for 40 years, was surprised at the takeovers. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Clearly, they dont understand that this is a rule-breaker, and I usually arrange a gentle one-to-one tutorial with them to reinforce how much this is not allowed. Each week, MDPI and other questionable publishers hound Dr. Lee by email, asking her to review submissions that she considers shoddy. The FTC noted that OMICS made false statements that some of its journals were included in PubMed and MEDLINE, two reputable academic-journal indexing services. This means were against the idea of copying a previous students essay, and were against paying someone to write your essay for you. The consequences of all this can be painful for unsuspecting academics. [For web sources]: The layout of my source is professional and recently updated. Your email address will not be published. This past year, when an undergraduate biology student at the University of the Fraser Valley approached dean of science Lucy Lee for $2,000 to publish a paper in an academic journal, Dr. Lee had immediate concerns about the request. Learn the rules of the game. When evaluating academic journals or books published by university presses, its always a good rule of thumb to ensure they are peer-reviewed and published in a reputable journal. If you use one of these in your research, it is probably a primary source. Whats more, many predatory journals want to use Canadas brand value, says Mr. Beall. Good teachers present YouTube videos in ways that are followed up with critique and analysis of the content within the video. However, the veracity and reliability of online news sources can vary enormouslybe sure to pay careful attention to authority here. Can the information you found be verified elsewhere, even via a simple Google search? And its right the vast majority of the time. Everyone just freaked out, she says. Youre right that you can figure out a predatory journal using its website, mainly by noting the basic errors, but its not true that an indicator is a substantial amount of articles published by academics on the global periphery. The global periphery, however you define it, has nothing to do with it, other than what I wrote in my article. Learn more about our academic and editorial standards. INQUIRIES Journal is an open-access academic journal established in 2009 that showcases the research of undergraduate students and above. Of those published in the journal, approximately 63% have completed or are pursuing a Bachelors degree, 26% hold or are pursuing a Masters degree, and roughly 11% have either completed or are completing a PhD, MD, or JD. reaching its goal in 2015 it cites a readership of 3.1 million in 185 countries, speaking both to its reach and to its quality as a publication target. That is a bad trend, he says. 1. The journal is a forum for presenting the best of philosophical thinking from a variety of perspectives. SORT TRUTH FROM FICTION Fraud-risk indications may be present in documents, reports, exception statistics and behaviors, and there are many effective discovery-based tests auditors can perform, including large sample sizes, computer-assisted audit techniques, observation, analysis and . It is itself subject to bias, as most things in research are. Wikipedia Okay, so here's the deal. Are there links to other sources on the page, and are they trustworthy? Work in Inquiries Journal comes from a mix of graduate (37%) and undergraduate students (63%). Your friends do, your competitors do, and even your teachers do. They often do not have single authors or publication dates, and their motivation can be more difficult to ascertain. Cite credible sources, not Wikipedia. I always choose traditional (even when I had a research grant before retirement), and guess what: after 6 months the articles become essentially open access .. However, in the social sciences and humanities given that history, culture and society are usually closely linked to language francophones are more likely to publish in French. I have checked that it is supported by evidence and/or verifiable elsewhere. To determine if a source is primary or secondary, ask yourself: Some types of source are nearly always primary: works of art and literature, raw statistical data, official documents and records, and personal communications (e.g. August 26, 2021 As you dig deeper into your scholarly research, books and academic journals are usually your best bet. How long will the review process take? There were none on my particular topic, which increases my chances and in 2015 they cite a 21.2% acceptance rate, which albeit competitive seems manageable, especially in the case that they may offer feedback for revision and re-application. Undergraduate research makes up about 60% of their publications, which is also in my favor. INQUIRIES Journal is an open-access academic journal that highlights the work of students at the undergraduate level and above. Your email address will not be published. I didnt want to be associated with anyone like that. She quit not long after the Dubai call and began sending emails to the AJPI journals where shed worked. For example, there is evidence suggesting poor interrater agreement among peer-reviewers, with a strong bias against manuscripts that report results against reviewers' theoretical perspectives [5]. in your field as a cheat sheet? We believe that an intellectually engaged society depends on an efficient marketplace of ideas. Sometimes a teacher wants their students to If it hasnt been updated recently, it may not pass the CRAAP test.